Saturday, March 17, 2007

Examining the Yanic Perreault Trade

At the trading deadline I pointed out that the Leafs likely paid too high a price for rent-a-player Yanic Perreault. That is quickly becoming apparent. Remember Perreault didn't address or fix any of the core needs of the club (penalty killing, defensive play, goaltending) and the price was too high.

Well, 7 games into the Perreault trade I have two more things to add to the list:
  1. The supposed depth on the Leafs defense is gone when they need it most.
  2. The Leafs knowingly traded Bell and a 2nd rounder for damaged goods.

If there's one-lesson to be learned from last year's playoffs it's that there's no such thing as having too many defense ( eg., Buffalo).

Now with injuries to Kaberle and Colaiacovo the Leafs had to rush back an injured Pavel Kubina and dress Wade Belak. McCabe logged 29 minutes against the Caps and will have to be good to go again Saturday night. I'd much rather have Bell available to fill-in on the blueline right now, but instead we have Perreault and his bum shoulder. Yes, JFJ picked up an injured player for his drive to the playoffs.

So to recap, that's our suddenly much needed depth on defense and a second round pick for this:

GameGA+/-Total TOIPP TOIPK TOI
at Washington 00-17:4700:3800:00
Tampa Bay0006:2400:5800:00
Ottawa---------Scratched----
at Ottawa00010:532:1400:00
Washington10+16:5100:4500:00
Buffalo00013:102:5300:00
at New Jersey0*0-113:384:1600:00

Dressed for six out of seven games, one goal, no assists, -1, average 09:47 ice time per game with no ice time killing penalty and 1:40 per game on the powerplay.

Wow. Nice work JFJ!